Stripe's built-in retention tools vs Churnly: what you still need
Start with Stripe. Smart Retries, failed-payment emails, expiring-card emails, a cancellation page with reasons and a retention coupon, pause, and rule-based automations all ship with Stripe Billing, and Stripe lists Smart Retries and recovery automations as included.
By the Churnly team. Updated November 21, 2026.
Stripe does not write to your customers as you would, run a monthly letter, or offer loyalty perks. That is the gap Churnly fills, from $19 a month on top of Stripe.
Side by side
| Churnly | Stripe | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $19, $49 or $99 a month by tracked MRR (up to $5,000, $25,000 or $100,000). AI is included. | Stripe lists Smart Retries, automatic reminders and recovery automations as included on its Billing pricing page. Billing pay-as-you-go is 0.7% of Billing volume. |
| Built for | Small subscription businesses on Stripe, run without a developer. | Every business that bills subscriptions through Stripe. |
| Billing platforms | Stripe only. | Stripe only, naturally. |
| Setup | Connect Stripe with a restricted key, then your email or WhatsApp. Nothing to install in your product. | Settings in the Dashboard under Billing, Revenue recovery. No code. |
| Failed payments | Spots declined cards and drafts the email or WhatsApp message, plus a payment retry, for you to approve. | Smart Retries (up to 8 retries within 2 weeks by default for new accounts), emails after failed payments, expiring-card emails and automatic card updates. Hard declines are not retried until there is a new payment method. |
| Cancellations | Reacts to a scheduled cancellation in Stripe with a drafted save: a personal message, a coupon or a pause. No cancel page inside your app. | A customer portal cancellation page with a reason list, lost-benefit messages and one retention coupon. You can pause payment collection with pause_collection. |
| Win-back | Drafts win-back messages. | No win-back campaigns. Automations can send a cancellation confirmation email, optionally with a reason survey. |
| Personal letters and loyalty | A personal letter each month, in your voice, plus loyalty tiers and perks. | No personal letters or loyalty perks. |
| You approve each message | Every message, coupon, pause and retry waits for your approval. Auto-send is off by default. | Rules run on their own once configured. Automations have six triggers and a short list of actions. |
Who should pick which
Choose Stripe if
- You have not set up Smart Retries, failed-payment emails or the portal cancellation page yet. Do that first. It costs nothing extra.
- Your volume is small and the default emails are enough.
- You only need rule-based behaviour: retry policies by segment, team notifications, a cancel confirmation.
Choose Churnly if
- You want a message written for this customer, in your voice, instead of a template.
- You want something to act on a scheduled cancellation or a downgrade with a drafted save.
- You want monthly letters, win-back and loyalty perks that Stripe does not have.
A retention app on top of Stripe
Churnly connects to the Stripe account you already have and leaves Stripe's own recovery settings in place. It reads customers, subscriptions and billing events through a restricted Stripe key. A declined card, a scheduled cancellation, a downgrade or an abandoned checkout becomes a drafted save that waits in one queue. You approve it in the app or on WhatsApp, and only then does anything go out or change in Stripe.
It starts at $19 a month for up to $5,000 of tracked MRR, with $49 and $99 plans above that. The AI that writes the drafts is included. There is no free trial; you can cancel any time. See pricing or estimate what churn costs you with the churn calculator.
Trying Churnly
- Sign up and connect Stripe with a restricted key. The Connections screen lists the exact permissions.
- Connect your email, and WhatsApp if you use it, so messages come from you.
- Open the queue. Edit or approve the first drafts. Nothing sends before then.
Questions
Do I need Churnly if I use Stripe Smart Retries?
Smart Retries picks when to retry a card. It does not talk to the customer. Churnly drafts the message that explains the problem and asks for a new card, and the retry for you to approve.
Does Stripe offer discounts to people who cancel?
Yes. The customer portal can offer one retention coupon that you pick in portal settings.
Can Churnly change things in Stripe?
Once you approve a step, Churnly can send a coupon, pause a subscription, retry a payment or mark a perk in your Stripe account, with the permissions of the restricted key you give it.
Sources
Everything about Stripe on this page comes from the public pages below, read on November 21, 2026. Competitors change prices and features, so check the source before you decide. If something here is out of date, tell us at hello@hichurnly.com.
- Stripe: revenue recovery
- Stripe: Smart Retries
- Stripe: customer emails
- Stripe: customer portal cancellation page
- Stripe: pause payment collection
- Stripe: Billing automations
- Stripe Billing pricing
Keep reading
- Churnly vs ChurnkeyChurnkey is the more complete product. It has cancel flows you embed in your app, payment recovery campaigns, A/B testing and, on higher plans, AI offers. A shared Slack channel is in its plan table. Its cheapest plan is $250 a month billed yearly.
- Churnly vs Churn BusterChurn Buster is a managed service that says it has spent more than ten years on subscription churn. You pay a flat fee set by your MRR, from $269 a month for dunning or cancel flows, and its team helps tune the results.
- All comparisonsPrices and coverage for every tool, side by side.
- Reduce churn on StripeFailed payments, cancellations and win-back, in order.
Keep the customers you already have.
Connect Stripe and Churnly starts watching for failed payments and cancellations. Every message waits for your approval.
Start at $19/mo