Churnly vs Baremetrics Recover: dunning emails or drafted saves?
Baremetrics Recover is dunning software. When a payment fails, your processor retries the charge and Recover handles the conversation: timed emails, SMS, in-app banners and a hosted card-update form. Recover is listed at $129 a month.
By the Churnly team. Updated November 21, 2026.
Churnly starts at $19 a month and covers more than failed payments: cancellations, win-back, a monthly letter and loyalty perks. It drafts each message for you to approve rather than running a fixed sequence.
Side by side
| Churnly | Baremetrics Recover | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $19, $49 or $99 a month by tracked MRR (up to $5,000, $25,000 or $100,000). AI is included. | Recover is a $129 a month add-on, with a "recover more than your Baremetrics cost or your next month is free" guarantee. Its analytics plans are listed from $75 a month; its FAQ quotes $49, and annual plans get up to 35% off. |
| Built for | Small subscription businesses on Stripe, run without a developer. | Subscription businesses; Recover sits next to Baremetrics' analytics. |
| Billing platforms | Stripe only. | Stripe, Braintree and Recurly are named for card capture. |
| Setup | Connect Stripe with a restricted key, then your email or WhatsApp. Nothing to install in your product. | Says hundreds of businesses put dunning on autopilot in less than a day. No custom code. |
| Failed payments | Spots declined cards and drafts the email or WhatsApp message, plus a payment retry, for you to approve. | Seven emails by default, plus SMS, in-app banners and paywalls, card-expiry reminders and a hosted card-update form. It has no retry schedule of its own; your processor, such as Stripe Smart Retries, retries the card. |
| Cancellations | Reacts to a scheduled cancellation in Stripe with a drafted save: a personal message, a coupon or a pause. No cancel page inside your app. | A separate Cancellation Insights product ($129 a month) collects cancellation reasons. |
| Win-back | Drafts win-back messages. | Not listed on the pages we checked. |
| Personal letters and loyalty | A personal letter each month, in your voice, plus loyalty tiers and perks. | Not listed. |
| You approve each message | Every message, coupon, pause and retry waits for your approval. Auto-send is off by default. | Sequences run on the emails you choose to turn on and write. |
Who should pick which
Choose Baremetrics Recover if
- You already use Baremetrics for metrics and want recovery in the same place.
- You want SMS and in-app banners for failed payments.
- You want a fixed, measurable dunning sequence and attribution to each email.
Choose Churnly if
- You want one tool for failed payments, cancellations, win-back and letters at a lower monthly price.
- You want each message written for the customer and approved by you, not a fixed sequence.
- You do not need SMS or in-app banners, and prefer email or WhatsApp.
Baremetrics Recover alternative for small subscription businesses
If you are looking at Baremetrics Recover and the price or the setup feels like too much for your size, Churnly is the smaller option. It reads customers, subscriptions and billing events through a restricted Stripe key. A declined card, a scheduled cancellation, a downgrade or an abandoned checkout becomes a drafted save that waits in one queue. You approve it in the app or on WhatsApp, and only then does anything go out or change in Stripe.
It starts at $19 a month for up to $5,000 of tracked MRR, with $49 and $99 plans above that. The AI that writes the drafts is included. There is no free trial; you can cancel any time. See pricing or estimate what churn costs you with the churn calculator.
Trying Churnly
- Sign up and connect Stripe with a restricted key. The Connections screen lists the exact permissions.
- Connect your email, and WhatsApp if you use it, so messages come from you.
- Open the queue. Edit or approve the first drafts. Nothing sends before then.
Questions
Does Recover replace Stripe Smart Retries?
No. By its own description, Recover has no retry schedule and relies on your processor, for example Stripe Smart Retries, to retry the card.
Does Churnly send SMS?
No. Churnly sends email, and WhatsApp when you connect it.
Can Churnly show analytics like Baremetrics?
Churnly shows what it did and what came back. It is not a metrics dashboard, and Baremetrics is a stronger choice for MRR reporting.
Sources
Everything about Baremetrics Recover on this page comes from the public pages below, read on November 21, 2026. Competitors change prices and features, so check the source before you decide. If something here is out of date, tell us at hello@hichurnly.com.
Keep reading
- Churnly vs Churn BusterChurn Buster is a managed service that says it has spent more than ten years on subscription churn. You pay a flat fee set by your MRR, from $269 a month for dunning or cancel flows, and its team helps tune the results.
- Churnly vs StripeStart with Stripe. Smart Retries, failed-payment emails, expiring-card emails, a cancellation page with reasons and a retention coupon, pause, and rule-based automations all ship with Stripe Billing, and Stripe lists Smart Retries and recovery automations as included.
- All comparisonsPrices and coverage for every tool, side by side.
- Reduce churn on StripeFailed payments, cancellations and win-back, in order.
Keep the customers you already have.
Connect Stripe and Churnly starts watching for failed payments and cancellations. Every message waits for your approval.
Start at $19/mo